Yearning

The Spice of Spice

Shakiba Barghi

Is yearning really better than spice? Australian romance author and Bookfluencer (Bookish influencer), Tierney Page (@tierney.reads) certainly thinks so. In a video Tierney challenges the spice supremacy by coming down on the yearning side. But do these two really oppose each other in romance? 

We can enjoy intense yearning and spice under one roof (in our book – of course), like Tierney’s suggestion of Wilder at Heart where yearning and spice work together. In this fake-dating, forced-proximity romance novel, the main characters make a deal to pretend to be together in order to make Nora’s (female main character, or FMC) ex-boyfriend jealous and help Theo (male main character or MMC) win his family’s approval to carry the responsibility of their hotel business. Their opposites attract/ forced proximity situation starts to produce a long tension between the two. Readers are rewarded with the spicy “shower scene” after pages and pages of waiting, build-up, and delay. 

Tierney’s video is only one of the voices in the bookish online community preaching about yearning and asking for delayed gratification – a quick scroll through Bookstagram reveals a ton of results. 

Although discussing yearning as an affective recommendation tool might be recent, yearning itself is not a newcomer in romance fiction. Readers adore how Mr. Darcy yearns for Elizabeth while he’s struggling to choose her against his social duty,  how Mr. Knightley watches Emma and Frank Churchill from the sidelines while he himself is pining for her, and how Captain Wentworth carries the hurt of Anne’s rejection, his soul pierced, and “half agony, half hope” after years of separation . Later, we read (and watched) Damon Salvatore pine for Elena from the shadows, burning for his brother’s girlfriend,  how Edward Cullen longs for Bella, thinking he’s not good enough for her, and how Peeta Mellark loved Katniss long before she noticed him, and repeatedly put her survival ahead of his own.  

These obstacles, things that make it nearly impossible to get the girl, are what Tierney also discusses in her explanation of The Choice and Saving Six in the same Instagram video. In The Choice, the two main characters have known each other for years, but she ends up dating his brother. He is left “watching from the sidelines” and yearning for her. The obstacle in Saving Six is Joey’s (MMC) difficult home situation and his belief that he’s not good enough for her, making him push her away despite the attachment between them. 

But what does yearning do for readers that spice can’t? While spice levels show the amount of sexual explicitness in a romance book, yearning shows readers what amount of anticipation, tension, and delay is in the book and what happens before/around the final fulfillment and payoff. Kendal Ferrari (@kendallferrari), a self-identified bookworm, hobby collector, and homebody who posts her book recommendations on Instagram and TikTok, starts one of her Bookstagram videos by saying: “no, no, no, no… I’m not asking you if the book has spice, I’m asking if it has tension, banter, and unbearable yearning, because that’s what I’m looking for”. Other readers in the community echo Kendall’s sentiment in the comment section by calling yearning “the real flavor of a book” and “the spice of the spice”. 

Yearning MMCs, desperate for their women,  are especially popular with Bookstagram. There are specific qualities like desperation, obsession, devotion, pursuit, and longevity in yearning. Sometimes, according to Anna Page (@novelswithanna), this yearning materializes as a secret tattoo on his body, as proof of concealed but enduring devotion. Sometimes the yearning MMC is patient enough to wait ten years, but active enough to race across the country immediately when she needs him (Heathen and Honeysuckle by Sarah A Bailey). 

Although a great amount of obsession is involved with these yearning MMCs, readers do not merely want obsessive men. They love an understanding and patient MMC who waits, yearns, and pines until the FMC is ready, as Page  discusses in Promise Me Not in her Bookstagram reel. Mason Johnson, the MMC, falls for grieving single mom, Payton Baylor, embracing her baby boy, and patiently waits for her although she tries to push him away, fearing that loving Mason means betraying her deceased first love, the father of her son. Page calls this book one of her favorites and praises the male yearning in it, saying “patience of this man is unmatched ... he waits, and he yearns, and he pines for so long”. Readers sometimes feel the yearning in their bodies. Enelle (@o.enelle.o on Instagram) frames yearnings as a bodily reading experience that makes the heart ache, open, and empty in her list of “books with top tier yearning”.: “Men who would do anything and give up everything just to breathe the same air as their love.”  Here, the value of yearning is measured by what it does to the reader, rather than only being located in the fictional relationship. There is a limit to the pain though, as she reveals at the end of the video, keeping it from turning to frustration. She asks the community for recommendations, saying “If you guys have recs…let me know…I love yearning in my books, clearly”. She says she has been recommended to read A Love Letter to Whiskey and she’s read it but “didn’t like it at all” because it was “too toxic” and there was “not enough communication”. Apparently, not all pain is acceptable. 

Readers in these online bookish communities turn yearning into something that they can build community around.Tierney and Page ask viewers to  request, recommend, and rank. A conventional book suggestion might tell readers the trope, plot, or rating, but readers in online romance communities are offering each other the anticipated experience of reading. Liking a book is not enough: it has to promise the kind of feeling they’re after.  Tiny signals like a secret tattoo, ten years of waiting, or racing across the country: these micro-scenes stand in for the larger affective promise of the book. 

Coming back to the question that started this essay, is yearning better than spice, then? Or are they really competitors? They don’t need to be. The two act for different purposes and tell readers different things about the pleasures of reading romance. Spice levels give readers agency to choose their level of comfort for explicit sexual scenes. But yearning shows readers how much anticipation, build-up, and angst is involved in the story, something that many romance readers (at least according to Bookstagram) are after. This new currency can coexist with spicy content beautifully as the readers suffer along with the characters as they overcome their obstacles and (finally) get to the juicy stuff! 

__________

Shakiba Barghi is a researcher and PhD Candidate at the University of Melbourne researching platformed reading cultures and contemporary readership. Her work looks at how readers use spaces such as BookTok, Bookstagram and BookTube to discover and recommend books, build communities, express taste and identity, and reshape literary culture. She is particularly interested in the social, cultural and aesthetic life of reading online. 

Bookstagram content used:

Anna: https://www.instagram.com/reel/DRM3HbSjk9Q/?igsh=ODh3Zm1hcjE1cWVl

Enelle: https://www.instagram.com/reel/DXKu0wnyJzq/?igsh=MTJka3VrbjJ6eDZheA%3D%3D

Kendal: https://www.instagram.com/reel/DJH6ewOTDD5/?igsh=MWRvdzIzNG03a2ZwMg%3D%3D

Tierney: https://www.instagram.com/reel/DVW8N6Kk36y/?igsh=NjI1NHdja3FhbXhr





Shakiba Barghi

Next
Next

Sink or Swim